Technical article · Ship Repair

Ship Collision Damage Assessment: Hengyi and RPG Bristol on the Ghent–Terneuzen Canal

Ship collision damage assessment of Hengyi and RPG Bristol on the Ghent–Terneuzen Canal: hydrodynamics, towlines, impact energy and IACS Rec. 47.

Published
Reading time
12 min
Author
Seachios® Operations Hub · Technical operations
Share
Ghent–Terneuzen, the gap
On this page09
  1. 01What the public sources establish
  2. 02Ship collision damage assessment: mass comes first
  3. 03Blockage and ship-to-ship interaction in a confined canal
  4. 04The gap between a ship and her tugs
  5. 05Impact energy: the calculation record
  6. 06What IACS Rec. 47 really says about a dent
  7. 07Why one ship went to a yard and the other stayed at her berth
  8. 08The same response in a Brazilian port
  9. 09Questions about this collision

On Saturday 14 November 2026 the inland tanker RPG Bristol and the bulk carrier Hengyi touched on the Ghent–Terneuzen Canal. This ship collision damage assessment sets out what the public sources establish, then works through the hydrodynamics, the towline risk, the impact energy and what the class standard really says about a dent.

What the public sources establish

The Dutch maritime weekly Schuttevaer published the account on 19 November, with a video filmed from the tanker. AIS port-call records and the ships' published particulars fill in the rest.

The two ships
The two ships
TypeBulk carrier, Kamsarmax sizeInland motor tanker
IMO93986569800922
ENINot applicable02337327
FlagMarshall IslandsSwitzerland
Built20082017
Length overall228.99 m110.00 m
Beam32.26 m11.45 m
Draught12.3 m, as her AIS reported it3.21 m, from her builder's sheet
Deadweight82,518 tNot in the sources read
Gross tonnage43,158Not in the sources read
Hengyi: VesselFinder. RPG Bristol: her builder's sheet, the inland register, VesselFinder and FleetMon. Press reports round her beam to 11.4 m.
14 November 2026, as reportedStage 04 of 04
  1. 06:37 UTC

    Hengyi leaves Terneuzen

    AIS records her departure, bound for Ghent.
  2. Morning

    The contact

    With tugs running ahead of Hengyi, RPG Bristol, sailing from Ghent to the Terneuzen lock, comes between the tugs and the bulk carrier during the passage. Shortly afterwards the two ships touch.
  3. 09:28 UTC

    Hengyi at Ghent

    AIS records her arrival in the port of Ghent.
  4. Afterwards

    The tanker goes for repair

    RPG Bristol moors at Sluiskil for examination, then goes to Astro Shipyards in Raamsdonksveer for repair. Hengyi is reported lying at Ghent.

Visibility that morning

A November morning on this canal invites the assumption of fog. The measurements do not support it. The KNMI station at Westdorpe, beside the canal, logged no fog in any hour from 06:00 to 10:00 UTC, with horizontal visibility of 8–9 km at 07:00, 5–6 km at 08:00 and 18–19 km at 09:00. Fog did form inland: Woensdrecht, about 40 km to the north-east, logged it until about 09:00 UTC. The video from the tanker shows a low sun, open sky and the far bank.

Ship collision damage assessment: mass comes first

Any ship collision damage assessment begins with how much energy the structures have to absorb, and that depends on the two masses.

As a reference, the tanker at her full draught displaces about 3,640 t (110 × 11.45 × 3.21 m, block coefficient 0.90). Hengyi at the 12.3 m her AIS reports displaces about 75,000 t (228.99 × 32.26 × 12.3 m, block coefficient 0.83 on length overall), some 21 times as much. She passes 90,000 t only near her summer marks, which this canal's 12.5 m draught limit rules out, and in ballast she would be far lighter.

When two ships stay in contact after the blow, the energy their structures must absorb is:

Ed=12 Mb MsMb+Ms vn2Mi=mi (1+Cm,i)\begin{aligned} E_d &= \frac{1}{2}\,\frac{M_b\,M_s}{M_b + M_s}\,v_n^2 \\ M_i &= m_i\,(1 + C_{m,i}) \end{aligned}

Here b is the striking ship, s the struck ship, Cm the added mass of the water each carries with her, and vn the speed normal to the side.

How much of the impact the steel must absorb
How much of the impact the steel must absorb
Hengyi's massAbsorbed, no sway added massAbsorbed, sway added mass 1.0Speed she picks up from a 4-knot blow
45,000 t, light92.2%95.9%0.16–0.31 kn
75,000 t, about 12.3 m95.2%97.5%0.10–0.19 kn
96,000 t, summer marks96.2%98.0%0.08–0.15 kn
Reference parameters: tanker 3,640 t with a surge added mass of 0.05. With only 1.2 m under the keel the true sway added mass is above 1.0, which pushes the share higher.

The side of the bulk carrier therefore behaves almost like a fixed boundary. The tanker stops, the large ship barely moves, and nearly all the kinetic energy goes into deforming steel. The result hardly changes with her loading, so her unknown condition does not weaken it. How the energy divides between the tanker's bow and the bulk carrier's shell depends on which yields first, and that takes both sets of scantlings and a finite-element model.

Blockage and ship-to-ship interaction in a confined canal

The canal is about 150 m wide in its Dutch reach and 13.5 m deep, and takes ships of up to 12.5 m draught. At 12.3 m, Hengyi would have about 1.2 m under her keel. A depth-to-draught ratio of 1.10 sits far inside the shallow water that the UK's MGN 199 (M) defines as depth less than twice the draught.

The blockage factor compares the ship's immersed midship section with the canal's:

S=AmAc=32.26×12.3×0.99150×13.5≈0.19S = \frac{A_m}{A_c} = \frac{32.26 \times 12.3 \times 0.99}{150 \times 13.5} \approx 0.19

The water the hull pushes aside has to return past her through what is left of the section, so it speeds up and the level drops alongside.

Return flow and drawdown alongside the bulk carrier
Return flow and drawdown alongside the bulk carrier
Ship's speedReturn flowWater-level drop
4 kn1.0 kn0.12 m
6 kn1.7 kn0.31 m
8 kn2.5 kn0.64 m
One-dimensional continuity and energy on a rectangular section of 150 × 13.5 m, at reference speeds. Sloped banks shrink the real section, so these are lower bounds. In the 200 m Belgian reach S falls to about 0.15.

This is the pressure field a smaller ship sails into. MGN 199 describes positive pressure at the bow and stern and negative pressure amidships, an interaction that grows roughly with the square of the speed, and a smaller vessel that feels the greater effect. When two ships meet, their bows tend to repel each other, and the guidance warns that this can itself lead to a critical situation.

For a small ship running down the side of a large one, the order matters. The pressure at the other's bow first pushes her head away. As her fore body draws level with the low-pressure zone, while her stern is still in the high-pressure one, the pair of forces turns her bow in toward the larger hull. The guidance for dissimilar ships working close is very slow speed, or for the smaller one to keep clear of the hazardous area off the other's bow. Whether this played a part on 14 November is for an inquiry to say.

The gap between a ship and her tugs

The video shows tugs running ahead of Hengyi and a line from her bow to the nearer one. That gap is one of the worst places for a third ship, for three separate reasons.

Situation plan to scaleSituation plan to scale. Both ships and the canal's width follow their published figures. The tugs are schematic, and the track, the contact and the angle θ are references, not a reconstruction.
01Fouling
A towline under load crosses the gap at a height set by its catenary. A passing ship can catch it on a mast, rail or deck fitting, and a slack line near the surface can reach her rudder or propeller.
02Snap-back
A line that parts recoils along its own path with the energy stored in it. UK MAIB report 15/2022 describes a parted pennant that shattered a tug's wheelhouse window and injured five of her crew.
03Girting
A line dragged across a tug's beam can heel her until she capsizes. A third ship pulling on that line creates exactly this sideways load.

Impact energy: the calculation record

The energy in the striking ship, with the water she carries along, is:

Ek=12 mb (1+Cm) vn2E_k = \frac{1}{2}\,m_b\,(1 + C_m)\,v_n^2

The mean crushing force is that energy divided by the depth of crushing, F = Ek / d.

Impact energy at 2, 4 and 6 knots
Impact energy at 2, 4 and 6 knots
Normal speedv_nEnergy E_kMean force, 0.5 m crushMean force, 1.0 m crush
2 kn1.03 m/s2.0 MJ4.0 MN2.0 MN
4 kn2.06 m/s8.1 MJ16.2 MN8.1 MN
6 kn3.09 m/s18.2 MJ36.4 MN18.2 MN
Reference parameters, not measurements: m_b = 3,640 t (110 × 11.45 × 3.21 m, Cb 0.90, water at 1.0 t/m³) and C_m = 0.05. An upper bound: the tanker at full draught against a rigid side.

Doubling the speed quadruples the energy. Only the speed normal to the side counts, vn = vrel · sin θ: ships closing at a combined 8 knots that touch at 22° have a normal speed of about 3 knots. Put your own case through the same formula:

Impact energy for your own case
Mass, t3,639
Energy, MJ8.1
Mean force, MN16.2
Illustrative: water at 1.0 t/m³, a rigid side and a mean force over the crush depth. It does not replace a structural analysis.
Contact in isometricA reference case in isometric: a bow on a side shell, the normal force Fn and the tangential force Ft on the plate, the zone of metal-to-metal friction, and the perimeter a cofferdam would seal for a repair afloat. No source states where the two ships actually met.

What IACS Rec. 47 really says about a dent

Recommendation 47 is the IACS Shipbuilding and Repair Quality Standard. Part A covers new construction and Part B the repair of existing ships. Its fairness tables give tolerances in millimetres.

Fairness of shell plating in IACS Rec. 47, Rev. 10
Fairness of shell plating in IACS Rec. 47, Rev. 10
Between frames, parallel part4 mm8 mm
Between frames, fore and aft part5 mm8 mm
With frames, parallel part±2 l/1000±3 l/1000
With frames, fore and aft part±3 l/1000±4 l/1000
Tables 6.10 and 6.11. l is the span of the frame in mm, at least 3,000 mm.
Side shell, δ and sA typical Kamsarmax midship section, not Hengyi's own drawings. A tanker loaded to 3.21 m reaches the side about 9 to 14 m above the bulk carrier's keel: the hold's side shell and frames, between the hopper and topside tanks. Detail A shows δ and s as Rec. 47 measures them.

That band matters. In a single-side-skin bulk carrier, the plating between the hopper and topside tanks is the hold's only boundary with the water, so a breach there floods the cargo space rather than a ballast tank.

Rec. 47's figures are workmanship tolerances, not a rule for accepting collision damage. The class surveyor decides, and the decision follows what the survey finds.

What the survey finds and what usually follows
What the survey finds and what usually follows
FindingUsual outcome
Fracture, breach or water ingressRepair before sailing, permanent or temporary as agreed with class
Frame tripped or detached, bracket crackedRepair before sailing
Dent past the fairness limit, plate and welds soundRepair, or a Condition of Class with a due date
Dent within the limit, UT and NDT cleanRecorded, no repair required
General practice, always at the class surveyor's decision.

Why one ship went to a yard and the other stayed at her berth

The reports give the destinations, not the reasons, but the engineering logic is general. A 110 m inland tanker can reach a yard with a slip or dock within the waterway network, and her size makes a dry repair quick to arrange.

A laden Kamsarmax is a different problem. Docking her means discharging first and finding a dock for 229 × 32 m, so the first step is a survey where she lies. If class accepts the hull as it is, or accepts a repair afloat, she can go on trading. Under a time charter, each day she cannot perform may put her off-hire at the rate the charter party states, so that survey sets the cost of the whole incident. No source says what survey Hengyi has had.

The same response in a Brazilian port

When a ship is damaged in a Brazilian port, a ship collision damage assessment follows the same order, with the class surveyor involved from the first call. Our teams for ship repair afloat and underwater services work through four steps, and the ship repair planner sizes the work packages.

  1. Underwater survey

    Commercial divers, with an ROV where it suits the job, examine the shell below the waterline and record it for class. Diving in Brazil follows the Maritime Authority's NORMAM-222/DPC. If the hull must be cleaned to be seen, NORMAM-401 governs the cleaning.
  2. Hold and tank mapping

    Inside the hold and the adjacent ballast tanks, the team maps frames, brackets and plating with ultrasonic thickness, magnetic particle and dye penetrant tests, on calibrated equipment accepted by class. Tank entry follows NR-33 and work at height NR-35.
  3. Repair afloat, agreed with class

    The method is agreed with the surveyor before work starts, as Rec. 47 Part B requires. Below the waterline a cofferdam gives the welders a dry space. Rec. 47 accepts welding on hull plating below the waterline of a ship afloat for local repairs on steels up to 355 MPa, with low-hydrogen consumables and preheat; anything more needs the society's special approval. Its standard insert is at least 300 × 300 mm, and doublers are normally temporary.
  4. Records for class

    Thickness readings, NDT reports and welding records go into one file the surveyor can accept.

Questions about this collision

Did fog cause the collision between Hengyi and RPG Bristol?
No source says so, and no cause has been published. The KNMI station at Westdorpe, beside the canal, logged no fog that morning and visibility of at least 5 km.
Does IACS Rec. 47 set a limit of δ/s ≤ 0.02?
No. It gives fairness tolerances in millimetres: for side shell plating between frames in the parallel part, 4 mm as the standard and 8 mm as the limit.
Why is the side of a large ship treated as almost rigid?
Because her mass is so much greater. With the reference figures, 96 to 98% of the striking ship's energy has to be absorbed by the two structures, and the large ship barely moves.
Who decides whether a damaged ship can keep trading?
The class surveyor, on what the survey finds: a repair before sailing, a repair afloat, or a Condition of Class with a due date.

Sources

  1. [Video] Bemanning RPG Bristol beleeft hachelijke momenten bij aanvaring met bulkcarrierSchuttevaer · 2026
  2. HENGYI, Bulk Carrier, IMO 9398656: particulars and port callsVesselFinder · 2026
  3. RPG Bristol: yard sheetVEKA Group
  4. RPG Bristol, ENI 02337327Binnenvaart.eu
  5. RPG BRISTOL, IMO 9800922FleetMon
  6. Hourly weather data, stations 319 Westdorpe and 340 Woensdrecht, 14 November 2026KNMI · 2026
  7. MGN 199 (M) Amendment 1: Danger of interactionUK Maritime and Coastguard Agency · 2026
  8. Recommendation 47: Shipbuilding and Repair Quality Standard, Rev. 10IACS · 2021
  9. On impact mechanics in ship collisionsMarine Structures, vol. 11, no. 10 · 1998
  10. Towline pennant failure destroys tug wheelhouse window, MARS 202318, from MAIB report 15/2022The Nautical Institute · 2023
  11. Ghent-Terneuzen CanalEncyclopaedia Britannica
  12. New lock opens access for larger ships at North Sea PortsThe Maritime Executive · 2025
  13. NORMAM-222/DPC: commercial divingBrazilian Navy, Directorate of Ports and Coasts · 2025

Put it to work

Cite this entry

Reference

Seachios® Operations Hub. Ship Collision Damage Assessment: Hengyi and RPG Bristol on the Ghent–Terneuzen Canal. Seachios®, SC-RPT-17, November 21, 2026. https://www.seachiosbrazil.com/press/ship-collision-damage-assessment-hengyi-rpg-bristol

BibTeX
@misc{seachios:sc-rpt-17,
  author = {{Seachios® Operations Hub}},
  title = {Ship Collision Damage Assessment: Hengyi and RPG Bristol on the Ghent–Terneuzen Canal},
  year = {2026},
  month = nov,
  howpublished = {Seachios®, SC-RPT-17},
  url = {https://www.seachiosbrazil.com/press/ship-collision-damage-assessment-hengyi-rpg-bristol}
}
SC-REQ-01Request for serviceOperations online · Santos --:--:-- BRT

ContactOperations hub · 24/7

Plan your next job in Brazil. Our operations hub replies 24/7.

Send the vessel, the port and the dates. We reply with a plan, a team and a timetable.

Response
30–60 min
Ports
12 · 04 Regions
Operations hub
Santos · 24/7

What to send

  1. 01The vessel and its IMO number
  2. 02The port, the berth or anchorage, and the dates
  3. 03The service, and what the work involves
  4. 04A plan from one of our tools, if you made one