Technical article · Cargo Holds

Cargo Hold Cleaning Planner: The Time and Risk Model

How the cargo hold cleaning planner sizes crews, days and risk in Brazilian ports: 500-bar robots, cargo routes, MARPOL and no cure, no pay.

Published
Reading time
12 min
Author
Seachios® Operations Hub · Technical operations
Share
The hold, two methods
On this page07
  1. 01Why hold cleaning fails before the ship reaches port
  2. 02The cargo hold cleaning planner's time model
  3. 03Robots on the flat, shore gangs on the structure
  4. 04Cargo transition matrix and applied chemistry
  5. 05MARPOL Annex V: residues and wash water
  6. 06No cure, no pay: scope, acceptance and exclusions
  7. 07Questions about hold cleaning time and risk

A hold that fails inspection is usually lost days before the surveyor climbs down the ladder: in the time allowed, the crews sent and the route chosen for the last cargo. The cargo hold cleaning planner (SC-TOOL-01) puts those decisions on one sheet before the ship arrives. This study sets out the model behind it, figure by figure.

Why hold cleaning fails before the ship reaches port

The failure has a familiar shape. The ship is fixed for grain after petcoke, the time at anchorage is assumed rather than worked out, and the crews are booked when the ETA firms up. If the holds are then rejected, the loss depends on the charter: off-hire, a notice of readiness that does not count, or a laycan that closes with the ship still washing. Rework and a second inspection come on top.

Who says no also matters, because the parties named in a fixture do different things.

Who judges a hold, and on what
Who judges a hold, and on what
RoleWhat it looks at
MAPA (Vigiagro)Brazil's agricultural authority at ports and terminalsControls on agricultural exports
Charterer's or shipper's surveyorNamed in the charter or sale contractThe agreed standard, hold by hold
P&I club surveyorActs for the shipowner's insurer when appointedCondition of the holds and evidence for a claim
GAFTA and NAEGATrade associations with standard grain contracts, not inspectorsThe contract may set the hold's condition and who certifies it
USDA FGISExamines stowage for grain exported from the United StatesClean, dry, free of infestation, rodents, toxic substances and foreign odour
Roles as each body or rule describes them. The charter party decides which of them applies to a given fixture.

USDA does not inspect ships in Brazil. Its rule, 7 CFR 800.75, matters here because it is the plainest statement of what a grain hold must be, and our grain-clean preparation works to the same criteria.

The corridors where this pressure is highest are the bulk ports where our crews work: Itaqui, with Ponta da Madeira and Alumar beside it, Santos, Paranaguá, Vitória, Rio Grande and Vila do Conde.

From the ship's data to a plan you can audit

The cargo hold cleaning planner takes what the master or operator already knows and returns a plan anyone can check:

INThe ship
Class from Handysize to Post-Panamax, and one to ten holds.
INThe cargoes
Seven last cargoes and nine next cargoes, which set the standard and the route.
INThe call
Anchorage or berth, 1 to 15 days of stay, one to four crews of 12 to 14.
OUTThe plan
Days and shift hours, the fit against the stay, the first-inspection risk and the method, in a PDF with a live QR code.

The plan carries no price. It exists to settle the technical question first: does this job fit this stay?

The cargo hold cleaning planner's time model

Every estimate starts from a reference job: five holds, two crews of 12 to 14, five hydro-jet units at 500 bar and an easy last cargo.

Reference times by cleaning standard
Reference times by cleaning standard
StandardNext cargoWorking daysShift hoursCeiling
Hospital cleanWoodpulp, alumina3–433–444 days
Grain cleanSoybeans, corn, sugar2–322–334 days
Normal cleanFertiliser, iron ore, coal, steel products2–2.522–27.54 days
Five holds, two crews, five 500-bar units, an easy last cargo, shifts of 07:00–18:00 (11 h). Source: the planner's engine. The charter party can call for another standard than the planner's default.

The reference is then scaled. Each end of the range is worked the same way, rounded outward to the half day and held under the ceiling:

EQ. 01
T=min⁡(4, [ (D⋅s+a)(h5)0.458(2c)0.2]12)T = \min\left(4,\ \left[\,(D \cdot s + a)\left(\frac{h}{5}\right)^{0.458}\left(\frac{2}{c}\right)^{0.2}\right]_{\frac{1}{2}}\right)
T working days · D reference days · s last-cargo factor · a add-ons · h holds · c crews
The planner's multipliers
The planner's multipliers
Value
Holds1 / 3 / 5 / 7 / 9 / 10×0.478 / 0.791 / 1.000 / 1.167 / 1.309 / 1.374
Crews1 / 2 / 3 / 4×1.149 / 1.000 / 0.922 / 0.871
Last cargoCoal, iron ore, grain×1.00
Last cargoMetcoke, fertiliser×1.05
Last cargoPetcoke×1.10
Last cargoClinker×1.15
Add-onMechanical scraping+0.25 day
Add-onAnti-rust treatment+0.25 day
Add-onAirless painting (already inside hospital clean)+0.5 day
Factors of the planner's engine, to three decimals. Add-ons are days added to the reference.

The full tables are open data: standard times (CSV) and multipliers (CSV).

Three behaviours follow:

  • Holds scale less than linearly. The exponent is set so that seven holds take 3.5/3 of the time of five. A seven-hold ship to grain clean goes from 2–3 days to 2–3.5: about half a day on the upper limit.
  • Crews have diminishing returns. Going from one crew to two saves 13%, from two to three 7.8%, from three to four 5.5%. Holds share ladders, hoses, lighting and hatch access, so a fourth crew helps most when the job is already against the ceiling.
  • The last cargo moves the top of the range first. Petcoke adds 10%, clinker 15%. After rounding, petcoke to grain clean reads 2–3.5 days instead of 2–3.
The upper estimate for your own job
Days, before rounding3.85
Shift hours at 11 h42
Illustrative. The planner rounds this up to the half day and never plans past four days.

Reading the fit against the stay

The planner compares the stay with both ends of the estimate. It fits when the stay covers the top of the range, is tight when it covers only the bottom, and overruns when it is shorter than both. The risk of failing a first inspection then rises with the standard, the last cargo and how little time is left; scraping and rust treatment bring it down.

Board 02, laytime and crewsBoard 02. Above, the stay window for a dirty-bulk last cargo (petcoke) by next standard. Below, the estimate with one to four crews. Half-day rounding is why two and three crews can read the same.Swipe to read the whole sheet

Where 36 hours fits

Our robotic 500-bar hydroblasting units can finish five holds in 36 hours, and that figure is often quoted without its context. Thirty-six hours is a little over three shifts of 11 hours: inside the planner's range for a hospital clean and just past the top of a grain clean's 33. It describes the washing capacity of the robotic units on a well-prepared job, not a promise for every ship.

Robots on the flat, shore gangs on the structure

More than 180,000 holds cleaned since 1980 have taught one division of labour. Remote-controlled units wash tank tops and bulkheads at 500 bar (7,250 psi) and 30 L/min. Hand-held fan and rotary jets reach what a robot cannot: ladders, stringers, hopper corners, side frames, topside slopes and hatch coamings. Where the height calls for it, the team works from a cherry picker under a permit to work. That combination is behind the up to 95% reduction in laycan downtime in the company's record.

Board 01, cleaning zonesBoard 01. A reference Supramax hold in section and in length: the band is the robots' surface, the ticked line the shore gang's. The zones are schematic and no reach is dimensioned.Swipe to read the whole sheet

Cargo transition matrix and applied chemistry

The route depends on what is coming out and what is going in. The planner holds a route for each pair, from two steps (grain to a normal clean) up to nine (clinker to hospital clean).

From the last cargo to grain clean
From the last cargo to grain clean
What governs the job
CoalCoal-dust degreaser7Dust sticks to the paint: chemicals go on before the rinse
Petcoke, metcokeHeavy-duty degreaser7Oily film, the hardest change to grain
ClinkerCement and clinker remover8Never wet it before the bulk is out: it sets like concrete
Iron oreNone to grain5Staining and loose scale
FertiliserNone to grain5Fresh water only, then a chloride test
GrainNone3Sweep and blow down; wash only if infested or wet
Routes of the planner's method. A hospital clean adds a chemical pass.

The chemistry follows the residue: alkaline degreasers for coal, petcoke and metcoke, descalers for clinker and cement, neutral detergents for grain and sugar, neutralisers for fertiliser and salts, and phosphating to treat rust and passivate the steel. The products are biodegradable and dosed to the residue. Each must also suit the paint and the next cargo, as Britannia P&I's guidance stresses, and goes on only with its safety data sheet read. Sulphur is outside the planner's list; a sulphur job is planned with the operations hub.

The seven-step standard route

This is the planner's route for the most common job, coal or petcoke to grain clean:

  1. Sweeping and dry removal

    Residues, lashings and dunnage come out dry, and the bilge wells are cleared. Clinker is chipped at this stage, before any water touches it.
  2. Sea-water pre-wash

    Fire hoses knock down dust and loosen what has set. A fertiliser hold skips this step: sea water would add salt.
  3. Cargo-specific chemical treatment

    A biodegradable product chosen for the residue goes on and is left to work for the time its data sheet gives.
  4. Sea-water wash

    The chemical and the loosened residue are washed off.
  5. Fresh-water hydrojetting at 500 bar

    Robots on the tank top and bulkheads, shore gangs on the structure. This pass removes the chlorides and the last of the chemical.
  6. Controlled drying and ventilation

    Holds and bilge wells are dried with forced ventilation. A hold that is still damp fails, however clean it looks.
  7. Internal quality control

    Before the inspector arrives, a white-rag test on the surfaces and, where the cargo history or the contract calls for it, a silver nitrate check for chlorides.

MARPOL Annex V: residues and wash water

Hold cleaning produces waste, and MARPOL Annex V decides where it can go.

01HME or not
The shipper classifies a solid bulk cargo as harmful to the marine environment (HME) or not, against the criteria of Appendix I, and declares it.
02HME residues
They may not be discharged at sea: they go to port reception facilities.
03Cleaning agents
A product in wash water discharged overboard must not itself be harmful to the marine environment. The ship should hold the supplier's statement.
04Records
Cargo residues are entered in Part II of the Garbage Record Book, and the cleaning log should show what was used and when.

In our work the rule is simpler than the exceptions: solid residues and wash water from a cleaning in port are delivered to licensed reception facilities, nothing goes overboard, and the receipts join the ship's documents. Plan the wash water early. As Skuld warns, a ship's bilge system may not be designed or approved to handle contaminated wash water, so portable pumps and hoses may be needed.

No cure, no pay: scope, acceptance and exclusions

No Cure, No Pay hold cleaning means one thing in practice: you are invoiced only when the independent surveyor accepts the holds. If a hold is rejected, our crews clean it again before any charge applies. For that to work, the contract states what acceptance is.

Acceptance criteria
Acceptance criteria
Grain clean
Previous cargoNo residueNo residue or stain
ConditionClean, dry, free of odour and gasCompletely clean and dry
Rust and scaleLoose scale removed; hard rust may remainNo loose scale
PaintNo loose flakesFully intact on every surface
As P&I guidance describes the grades. There is no single universal definition, so the charter party's wording prevails.

The undertaking covers the cleaning within the agreed scope. These lie outside it, and are best written into the contract from the start:

Questions about hold cleaning time and risk

How long does it take to clean five holds to grain clean?
In the planner's reference case, two to three working days of 11 hours, with two crews of 12 to 14 and five 500-bar units after an easy last cargo. After petcoke or clinker the top of the range becomes 3.5 days.
What is the longest a cleaning can take in the planner?
Four working days. Holds, cargo and add-ons all push the estimate up, but the planner holds it at that ceiling and sizes the teams to stay inside it.
Do more crews always make the job faster?
Yes, but by less each time. The factors are 1.149, 1.000, 0.922 and 0.871 for one to four crews. Because the plan rounds to the half day, two and three crews can show the same range.
Does USDA inspect holds in Brazil?
No. USDA's stowage examination applies to grain exported from the United States. In Brazil the inspection is set by the charter or sale contract and by the Brazilian authorities, and the USDA criteria remain a useful yardstick.
Is a silver nitrate test proof that a hold is salt-free?
No. It indicates chlorides but not their amount or source, and it can react to traces. It is a useful check before the inspector arrives, not a certificate.
What does no cure, no pay exclude?
Pre-existing structural defects, failed coatings or severe corrosion, a lack of the ship's fresh water or power, port or time limits, and criteria not shared in advance. The contract for each job sets the exact wording.

Run your own case in the cargo hold cleaning planner, then compare it with our cargo hold cleaning services in Brazilian ports.

Sources

  1. Cargo hold cleaning standards: hold washing, inspection and pollution preventionBritannia P&I · 2025
  2. Hold cleaning of bulk vesselsThe Swedish Club · 2022
  3. Cargo Hold Cleaning, Loss Prevention BulletinWest of England P&I
  4. Hold Cleaning: when is clean, clean enough?Steamship Mutual · 2017
  5. Hold Cleaning: the legal issuesUK P&I Club · 2021
  6. The purpose and limitations of Silver Nitrate TestingGard · 2022
  7. Prevention of Pollution by Garbage from Ships (MARPOL Annex V)International Maritime Organization
  8. Class News 05/2018: revised MARPOL Annex VLloyd's Register · 2018
  9. Guidance on disposal of cargo residues in line with MARPOL Annex VSkuld · 2017
  10. 7 CFR § 800.75: Kinds of official inspection and weighing servicesLegal Information Institute, Cornell Law School
  11. Vigilância agropecuária: importação e exportaçãoMinistério da Agricultura e Pecuária (MAPA)
  12. The Grain and Feed Trade AssociationGAFTA
  13. NAEGA No. 2 ContractNorth American Export Grain Association

Put it to work

T-01Hold cleaning plannerWhat a cargo change requires: standard, days, inspection risk and methodOpen the tool

SVC-01 · the service

Cargo Hold Cleaning

Holds of bulk carriers brought to the next cargo’s standard by in-house crews and robotic units in every major Brazilian port.

Cite this entry

Reference

Seachios® Operations Hub. Cargo Hold Cleaning Planner: The Time and Risk Model. Seachios®, SC-RPT-18, November 21, 2026. https://www.seachiosbrazil.com/press/cargo-hold-cleaning-planner-time-risk-model

BibTeX
@misc{seachios:sc-rpt-18,
  author = {{Seachios® Operations Hub}},
  title = {Cargo Hold Cleaning Planner: The Time and Risk Model},
  year = {2026},
  month = nov,
  howpublished = {Seachios®, SC-RPT-18},
  url = {https://www.seachiosbrazil.com/press/cargo-hold-cleaning-planner-time-risk-model}
}
SC-REQ-01Request for serviceOperations online · Santos --:--:-- BRT

ContactOperations hub · 24/7

Plan your next job in Brazil. Our operations hub replies 24/7.

Send the vessel, the port and the dates. We reply with a plan, a team and a timetable.

Response
30–60 min
Ports
12 · 04 Regions
Operations hub
Santos · 24/7

What to send

  1. 01The vessel and its IMO number
  2. 02The port, the berth or anchorage, and the dates
  3. 03The service, and what the work involves
  4. 04A plan from one of our tools, if you made one